All News
faaair-traffic-controlinfrastructureaviationai-adoption

The FAA put $875M of AI advice in all 22 centers. Three days later the analog gear failed

The FAA expanded its AI tool SMART to all 22 air traffic centers on 10 November. Three days later, a telecom failure caused the third ground stop in history.

Vlad MakarovVlad Makarovreviewed and published
6 min read
The FAA put $875M of AI advice in all 22 centers. Three days later the analog gear failed

On 10 November the Federal Aviation Administration said its AI advisory tool would be used in the airspace of all 22 of its Air Route Traffic Control Centers. On Friday 13 November, at 3:36 pm Eastern, the agency stopped every flight in the country for about five hours. SMART played no part in that failure, and the mechanism says it could not have: what broke were the communications links between the centers, gear the Transportation Secretary calls decades old and analog. The timing still shows the shape of the bet.

What the tool actually does

SMART stands for Strategic Management of Airspace, Routes and Trajectories. It is cloud software built by Air Space Intelligence under a 12-year, $875 million contract awarded in June, the Washington Times reported. Per the department's own fact sheet, it centralises "weather patterns, flight paths, arrival/departure statistics, controller staffing metrics" into one platform to forecast traffic, make scheduling recommendations, pick routes and set arrival order.

It started on 21 September over the Washington airspace around Reagan National, Dulles and BWI, then spread to the Atlanta, Jacksonville and Miami centers, Ars Technica reported. Tuesday's notice made it national, in the agency's words: "After a successful initial rollout to the National Capital Region in September, the FAA will now use SMART in the airspace of all 22 centers across the country to reduce delays, reduce fuel consumption and improve the travel experience for the flying public."

Three filters between the model and the sky

Every recommendation is validated by a team of FAA specialists in Washington before it reaches a control facility, and local controllers can accept or decline it. The agency is explicit that SMART "cannot be used to replace the critical role air traffic controllers play or take over control of an aircraft." Controllers keep separation.

That is honest design. It is also a precise description of how much unsupervised authority the model carries, which is none. The chain runs model, then a review desk, then a controller's discretion. A tool that needs two human gates before it changes one route is not flying anything, and the agency's own language says as much. So the expansion is a claim about the quality of advice, not autonomy, and the claim is being made by the same office that bought the system.

Five hours, and the third time in history

The stop began at 3:36 pm EST and was lifted at 8:35 pm, about five hours later. It was the third nationwide ground stop in the FAA's history, Ars Technica reported.

DateCauseDetail
11 September 2001Attacks on New York and WashingtonFirst in FAA history
11 January 2023NOTAM system outageUnder two hours
13 November 2026Communications failure across all centersAbout five hours

More than a million travelers were affected, and Air Canada cancelled all of its US-bound flights for the evening. Sean Duffy, the Transportation Secretary, described a "communication issue impacting all Air Route Traffic Control Centers" on X. Markwayne Mullin, the Homeland Security Secretary, was plainer: "This is a telecommunications outage out of the FAA. Out of an abundance of caution, we have grounded all of the flights. There's no indication as of yet that this is a nefarious attack against us."

The part that failed is not the part that was upgraded

After the lift, Duffy wrote that "Today's nationwide ground stop happened because our air traffic control system is operating on DECADES-OLD analog equipment that simply cannot compete with the demands of the 21st century," and warned there would be "more of these" without massive system updates.

Air Space Intelligence said the same thing in its own words: "The current ground stop is not based on or a result of the SMART system, any product of ASI or our integration with FAA and ATC."

Both statements are credible, and together they define the problem. SMART reasons about traffic flows. It does not sit on the telecom path that links one center to the next. The failure modes are disjoint: nothing the model recommends would have kept an analog link up, and an analog link going down says nothing about whether its advice is any good. A system can be well built and still be irrelevant to the outage that makes the news, and that is the more uncomfortable reading for anyone who assumed AI modernization and infrastructure modernization were the same budget line.

What the money bought so far

The FAA's published numbers: 180 flights rerouted since 21 September, saving about 10 minutes and nearly 80 gallons of fuel each. Across the seven and a half weeks it has run in the Washington airspace, that comes to 1,800 flight-minutes, thirty hours in total, and roughly 14,400 gallons of fuel.

The single Friday outage touched more than a million travelers. The two figures measure different things and the comparison is unkind to a system in its first weeks, but it is the only accounting the agency has offered. The one worked example given to the Dallas Morning News involved a cargo flight at DFW that the FAA did not identify, and the agency has not said how SMART assisted passenger traffic. Delta's Ed Bastian and American's Robert Isom both issued supportive statements when the earlier rollout was announced.

The contract term is the other number worth staring at. Twelve years from a June award runs to 2038. That is a long time to sell advice that sits on top of equipment the Secretary himself calls decades old and unable to compete, and Friday is what happens when the hardware gives out first.

The union was not in the room

The National Air Traffic Controllers Association, which represents more than 15,000 members, told Flying it was not consulted or involved in the "design, testing, or implementation of SMART and therefore cannot speak to its effect on the air traffic control workforce."

That is more than a routine grievance, because the fact sheet lists controller staffing metrics among the model's inputs. The people whose workload the advice is meant to smooth sat outside its design, its testing and its rollout. Whether they accept or decline a recommendation is the only feedback loop the system has, and nobody asked them what it should be measuring.

The distinction is easy to blur in both directions. A union endorsement would prove nothing about whether the arrival sequencing is sound. But a tool that reorders traffic advice for 15,000 people whose staffing numbers feed the model, shipped without their review, leaves the decline button as the sole check that runs at the scope.

What would settle it

Three things. The reroute log behind the 180 figure, with acceptance and decline rates from the Washington review desk. Whether SMART was running and being used during the five hours on Friday. And a public account of the telecom failure itself, since the Secretary has promised more of them. An AI layer can be useful and still be beside the point when the wires go down. Until both ledgers are published, the honest reading is that the agency has bought advice and left the equipment alone.

Related Articles

Scroll down

to load the next article