Anthropic's 87% gas estimate is a model, not a meter reading
A modeled 87% gas and 11% coal power mix would put Anthropic near 32 MtCO2e in 2028, with a range up to 38. It rests on a handful of contested assumptions.

Anthropic does not publish a site-by-site power breakdown, so on 16 November an advocacy group published one built from its contracts, permits and filings. The line that traveled was a percentage: roughly 87% of the company's power coming from gas and 11% from coal in 2028. That number reached the top of Hacker News on 22 November, where it drew about 800 points and more than 800 comments.
It is worth being precise about what it is. The Better Data Center Project built a model from public contracts, permits and filings, and the model says Anthropic's power use could produce 17 to 38 million tonnes of CO2 equivalent a year in 2028, with 32 as the mid-case. Nobody has measured that. The interesting question is not whether the model is right, but which of its choices would have to be wrong for the headline to fall apart.
What the arithmetic is actually built on
The project is not a neutral party. Its October report argued that "bring your own power" gas is becoming the default for AI campuses, and its estimate that less than 20% of proposed on-site generation will be renewable by 2032 is an argument as much as a finding. What makes it usable is that it works from Anthropic's paper trail, not a survey.
Of 15 GW of compute contracted as of October 2026, the authors could tie 5.9 to 9.6 GW to named data-centre sites. That is the whole denominator; cloud capacity with no disclosed address is left out. For each named site they assigned a power source, using permit emissions factors where a campus has on-site turbines or a dedicated new grid plant, and the EPA's AVERT model where it does not. AVERT estimates which existing plants in a region absorb new load, which is why the report says marginal rather than average.
Nine point six gigawatts, the authors note, is about 7 million homes or 18% of California's peak demand.
A range that is really three numbers
The mid-case 32 MtCO2e sits beside figures that were reported, not modeled, and that is where the shock value comes from.
| Benchmark | MtCO2e per year | Period |
|---|---|---|
| Anthropic, mid-case | 32 | 2028, modeled |
| Anthropic, full range | 17-38 | 2028, modeled |
| California power sector | 31.1 | 2024, actual |
| Meta, Microsoft, Google combined Scope 2 | 32.9 | 2025, location-based |
| Entire US data-centre sector | 105 | 2024 |
Read the columns carefully. A footnote concedes that comparing 2025 corporate figures with a 2028 estimate is not meant to suggest Anthropic will be the largest emitter among tech companies, since their emissions are growing too. Much of the tonnage may never appear on Anthropic's carbon account: for space leased inside Amazon's or SpaceX's facilities, the electricity is likely booked as Scope 2 by the owner and Scope 3 by Anthropic. The physical emissions are the same; the reporting line is not.
By the report's own arithmetic the mid-case adds 16 to 36% to the 2024 US data-centre sector and 1.1 to 2.5% to the country's whole power sector. Those are the sober numbers, and they are less quotable than "bigger than California".
The assumption carrying most of the weight
Carbon intensity is the hinge. The report estimates 1,033 to 1,076 lb CO2e per MWh for Anthropic's power, about 35% above the US grid average of 767. Footnote four gives the alternative: using average eGRID intensity for each subregion instead of AVERT's marginal rate yields 839 lb/MWh. That is a 9% premium over the national average rather than a 35% one.
Both are defensible. A new load built in 2028 is met by whatever is dispatchable at the margin, so marginal rates describe the near-term effect more honestly. But the choice is worth 200 lb/MWh and a good part of the headline, and it is a choice, not a measurement.
The other parameters are similarly load-bearing. Power usage effectiveness is assumed at 1.1 to 1.2, with 1.15 in the mid-case, and utilization at 60 to 80%, with 70% in the mid-case. The mid-case also assumes all 9.6 GW is online in 2028. A campus that slips a year drops out of the total entirely, and a fleet running at 60% utilization rather than 70% cuts the number by roughly a seventh. None of those are unreasonable. Together they are why the range spans 17 to 38.
Where the pollution actually lands
The CO2 total gets the attention; the air story is more concrete. About a quarter of the contracted power, 2.5 GW, is on-site gas behind the meter, and 80% of that capacity is simple-cycle turbines and reciprocating engines rather than combined-cycle plants. Those units emit more per megawatt-hour, and the report puts the fleet's annual output at more than 13,000 tons of NOx and 2,000 tons of PM2.5, which through EPA benefit-per-ton estimates converts to $2-3 billion a year in health damages.
Anthropic has contracted 460 MW from Nscale's Monarch campus in West Virginia, with talks reported for up to 920 MW, and the facility runs on reciprocating engines. It has also taken capacity at SpaceX's Colossus 2 since May 2026, up to 600 MW by the end of this year, which the Southern Environmental Law Center describes as powered by dozens of unpermitted turbines and is suing xAI over, on the NAACP's behalf. That allegation is about xAI's plant, not Anthropic's; Anthropic's policy requires permitting and selective catalytic reduction at plants powering its data centres. The gap the report is pointing at is structural: a policy can bind what a company builds and not what a landlord operates.
What the company has said, and what it has not
Anthropic's own infrastructure page is more candid than the headlines. "Much of that new power is natural gas, which can be brought online quickly, ramps up and down as demand changes, and is abundant in the places we're considering for data centers," it says, alongside a commitment to "broaden our energy mix with geothermal, wind, solar, and emerging technologies".
The report's first finding is narrower than it sounds: Anthropic has no publicly disclosed renewable commitments in the United States, with its only announced renewable contracts or investments in Norway and Canada. It contrasts that with 1.7 GW of heavy-duty gas generators bought for $3.4 billion, as reported by the Financial Times. Undisclosed is not nonexistent, and supplier terms can stay quiet without anything sinister. But a commitment nobody can point to is not yet a commitment.
The gap between dollars and megawatts
The report's most transferable move is converting a cloud contract into electrical load. SpaceX's revised June filing put the Anthropic deal at about $1.25 billion a month for roughly 325,000 Nvidia GPUs, which works out to an implied IT load near 490 MW. Anthropic's October prospectus shows the same arrangement expanded to about $3.1 billion a month, up to $120.5 billion through 2029.
Dollars, not megawatts. The authors doubt the increase is a proportional 2.5x in compute, citing a June Google-SpaceX agreement priced at roughly $11.5 per GPU-hour against about $5, and estimate the larger deal at perhaps 200,000 more GPUs and 400 MW, with 25% uncertainty either way. That is the honest state of the public record: the money is disclosed to the dollar and the electricity is inferred from it.
That is the useful takeaway from a post that spent a day at the top of Hacker News. The method is now public and repeatable, and the first lab to publish hourly, site-level fuel data would settle the argument in an afternoon. Until one does, the defensible sentence is "17 to 38 million tonnes, on stated assumptions", and the number in the headline is the least reliable thing in the report.


